Reproductive and human rights advocates on Thursday warned that first-degree murder charges against a woman in California for the death of her stillborn baby is “the direct result” of the anti-choice movement’s push for extreme laws pitting the rights of women against those of unborn children.
“Charging someone with murder for a stillbirth, under any circumstance, is dystopian.” —Callie Beusman, The Cut
Chelsea Cheyenne Becker was arrested and charged on Wednesday with murder in Hanford, California and held on $5 million bail, several weeks after giving birth to a stillborn baby. The baby was found to have toxic levels of methamphetamine in his system, suggesting to investigators that Becker had used the drug throughout her pregnancy.
Becker has reportedly struggled long-term with substance addiction; her three living children were born with meth in their systems and are in the custody of adoptive parents and family members.
As Hannah Gold wrote at The Cut, “murder charges are not an unfortunate but natural outcome of becoming pregnant while dealing with substance-abuse issues”:
Becker’s charges come five months after an Alabama woman, Marshae Jones, was charged with manslaughter for miscarrying a pregnancy after she was shot. Authorities accused her of starting a fight with the person who shot her. Outraged reproductive rights advocates linked Jones’s arrest to state Republicans’ embrace of the “fetal personhood” movement and Alabama’s extreme abortion ban.
Amnesty International published a report in 2017 condemning laws that criminalize women who abuse substances during pregnancy, saying such measures, which have been passed in recent years in states including Tennessee and Alabama, prevent women with abuse disorders from seeking prenatal care and drug treatment.
Those laws, Amnesty wrote, “claim to promote maternal and infant health [but] are in fact driving pregnant women away from vital health services, jeopardizing their well-being and violating their right to health.”
“Drug dependence is a health condition but U.S. authorities are treating it as a crime, failing to ensure treatment is available for pregnant women and then punishing them for their ongoing condition,” the group added. “These harsh and discriminatory laws are making pregnancy more dangerous and trampling on human rights in the process.”
SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT